Patriotic Narratives: Shaping American Gender Identity Through 19th-Century Literature
8 April 2025
Nineteenth-century American literature played an important role in shaping cultural understandings of gender, patriotism, race, and national identity. In his ongoing book project, Inventing American Gender: Nineteenth Century Literary Gender and its Uses, Eagan Dean, a postdoctoral fellow at the Clayman Institute, explores how American writers developed and represented gender systems through fiction, essays, autobiographical accounts, and archival materials published between 1797 and 1902. His research challenges the assumption that gender categories have always been fixed and clearly defined, arguing that literary representations of gender often served particular political and cultural purposes.
Dean’s research focuses on two influential literary works associated with the American Civil War: Walt Whitman’s Specimen Days and Louisa May Alcott’s Hospital Sketches. Both texts depict nursing and caregiving as activities through which conventional gender expectations could be challenged. By examining these narratives, Dean demonstrates how gender nonconformity could become a means of expressing patriotic commitment and contributing to national reconciliation. However, these representations also reveal how ideas about gender and national belonging were shaped by racial inequalities.
In Specimen Days, Walt Whitman presents himself as a compassionate caregiver who tends to wounded soldiers during the Civil War. Rather than portraying himself exclusively through conventional masculine ideals, Whitman adopts qualities associated with maternal care, including tenderness, emotional intimacy, and physical affection. His interactions with injured soldiers demonstrate how nurturing behavior could coexist with male identity. According to Dean, this combination of masculine and feminine characteristics allowed Whitman to present his caregiving activities as patriotic service, making his gender-nonconforming behavior socially meaningful within the context of wartime nationalism.
However, Whitman’s portrayal of care also reflects racial limitations. Although his writings acknowledge encounters with Black soldiers, his vision of national healing primarily emphasizes reconciliation among white men. His expression of gender fluidity therefore becomes closely connected to a particular understanding of American national identity, one that celebrates compassion and unity while leaving racial inequalities largely unresolved. This illustrates how seemingly progressive representations of gender could simultaneously reinforce existing political and racial hierarchies.
Louisa May Alcott’s Hospital Sketches offers another perspective through the character Tribulation Periwinkle, a nurse who embraces traditionally masculine characteristics and resists conventional expectations of femininity. Trib expresses dissatisfaction with the restrictions imposed on women and imagines the freedom associated with being a man. Through her nursing experiences, she combines maternal compassion with masculine confidence and camaraderie. Her character demonstrates how women could participate in patriotic activities by adopting behaviors that challenged the gender conventions of their time.
Despite Trib’s unconventional gender expression and occasional abolitionist sentiments, her relationships with Black characters remain limited by racial boundaries. Dean’s analysis suggests that, as in Whitman’s writing, gender nonconformity does not necessarily lead to broader social equality. Both literary works portray alternative gender roles as valuable within a patriotic framework, yet their visions of solidarity remain shaped by racial exclusion. Reading these narratives through trans studies and Black feminist criticism helps reveal the complex relationships between gender, race, power, and national belonging.
Ultimately, Dean’s research challenges the contemporary claim that gender diversity departs from an original, historically stable binary system. By examining nineteenth-century literary representations of gender experimentation, his work demonstrates that gender identities and expectations have long been shaped by cultural narratives, political interests, and social circumstances. It also highlights the contradictions between earlier portrayals of gender nonconformity as a form of patriotic service and modern arguments that present strict gender conformity as a return to traditional values. Through this historical perspective, Dean encourages readers to reconsider how literature constructs gender, influences collective identity, and shapes ongoing debates about the legitimacy and history of transgender and gender-diverse lives.